Fabric for the Dining Room Chairs

I want to recover the dining room chairs.   They have to be sent out to an upholsterer because they have a spring system in them (which is failing).

My living room / dining room are in an L shape. 

This is the dining chair as it is now ... covered in a steel blue velvet.

These are my choices of fabric:

and this shows the scale on the chair seat:

My love seat is a solid blue, two chairs are in beige, and I have another chair in a large Robert Allen fabric that I LOVE!

 I tending toward the small scale print ...but it might be too safe. I like the other too .... and it is not too close to clash with the chair pattern 

This is against the love seat fabric:

Where is Sarah Richardson, the Queen of Pattern, when you need her?

What do you think? 

Should I start over with other fabrics? 

PS:   after staring at these all night I think I will go with the one on the right side.  It is bolder.